9/11 survivors divided over ‘weird’ offer of affordable apartments —overlooking Ground Zero

[ad_1]

The ultimate monument to moving on — or a misguided attempt at reparations?

Survivors and first responders devastated by the 9/11 terrorist attacks are divided over news that they can apply for “affordable” apartments in a ritzy new building just steps from Ground Zero.

The 900-foot skyscraper, 5 World Trade Center, will be constructed at the corner of Greenwich and Albany streets in lower Manhattan and is set to feature 1,200 plush apartments — and haunting views overlooking the site where more than 2,900 New Yorkers were murdered.

As part of a new agreement brokered by Gov. Kathy Hochul, 80 of the building’s required 400 rent-stabilized units will be set aside for New Yorkers directly impacted by the attacks — but some survivors are baffled by the deal.

“I think it’s weird,” Marian Fontana bluntly told The Post. Her firefighter husband, David, was killed on 9/11, which also happened to be their eighth wedding anniversary.

The author, who lives in Brooklyn, bemoaned the lack of affordable housing in the Big Apple but has no plans to apply for one of the apartments.

“Would anyone want to live on the crash site where their loved one died?” Fontana, 57, asked. “I don’t want to even drive past there.”


Renderings of the skyscraper showed that it looked directly out onto the somber 9/11 Memorial Pools at Ground Zero.
Marian Fontana lost her firefighter husband, David, on Sept 11, 2001 — it was their eighth wedding anniversary. He chose the proposal date because he liked telling his firefighter friends he got married on 911.
Leslie Close

Online, others have expressed exasperation about the announcement after renderings of the skyscraper showed that it looked directly onto the 9/11 memorial pools at Ground Zero.

“Why would someone who went through a horrific experience and survived want to now live in that exact location?” one perturbed pundit pondered, while another declared: “Honestly wouldn’t want to live there if my loved one perished in that attack. Bad memories.”


5 World Trade Center, to be constructed at the corner of Greenwich and Albany Sts. in Lower Manhattan, will feature 1,200 plush apartments, including 400 rent-stabilized units for low-and moderate-income New Yorkers.
5 World Trade Center, to be constructed at the corner of Greenwich and Albany streets in lower Manhattan, will feature 1,200 apartments, including 400 rent-stabilized units for low-and moderate-income New Yorkers.
Silverstein Properties

 "I think it's weird," Fontana said of the plans to offer 9/11 survivors and first responders affordable apartments near Ground Zero. "Would anyone want to live on the crash site where their loved one died?"
“I think it’s weird,” Fontana said of the plans to offer 9/11 survivors and first responders affordable apartments overlooking Ground Zero memorial pools. “Would anyone want to live on the crash site where their loved one died?”
Kimberly Wang/Eardog Productions

‘My heart is down there. I don’t find it morbid — 9/11 is my whole life. I didn’t have kids, I didn’t get married … To be able to get a reasonably priced rental down there would enable me to do other things.”

Tim Brown, a retired FDNY firefighter who volunteers at the 9/11 Memorial, was 38 at the time of the attacks.

Households of three with an annual income between $50,840 and $152,520 will be eligible to apply for one of the 400 rent-stabilized apartments at 5 WTC -— with rents ranging from $1,271 to $3,813 a month.

However, it’s unclear whether those figures will also apply to the 9/11 survivors and first responders eligible for one of the 80 apartments set aside for them.

It also remains to be seen whether survivors and first responders will be chosen via a random lottery or whether their applications will be assessed by a team.

The Post has reached out to Gov. Hochul’s office for further information.

Brookfield Properties and Silverstein Properties are developing 5 WTC, with completion still several years away.

When asked about the application process for 9/11 survivors and first responders, both companies told The Post in a statement: “The specifics of the program are to be worked out with the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal.”


Rachel Uchitell lost her fiancé Andy O'Grady in the attacks. She is pictured on the cover of The Post on Sept. 14 2001.
Rachel Uchitel lost her fiancé, Andy O’Grady, in the attacks. She is pictured on the cover of The Post on Sept. 14, 2001.
New York Post

“There are a lot of questions,” Rachel Uchitel told The Post of the still murky application process.

The podcaster — who hosts Miss Understood with Rachel Uchitel — lost her fiancé, Andy O’Grady, in the attacks and said the trauma still lives on almost 22 years later.

“What do they mean by survivors?” Uchitel, 48, asked, admitting confusion about who could qualify for the plush pads. “Do they mean someone who was actually in the building? Or someone who lost a loved one and has never been able to get their act together?”

Fontana concurred, saying: “So many people are affected [by 9/11] that it could become contentious.”


Uchitel told The Post the trauma still lives on almost 22 years later.
AP

9/11 survivors and first responders are still struggling with the trauma of that fateful day almost 22 years on.
Survivors and first responders are still struggling with the trauma of that fateful day.
Getty Images

Rescue workers climb on piles of rubble at Ground Zero in 2001.
Rescue workers climb on piles of rubble at Ground Zero following the attack on Sept. 11, 2001.
AP

John Feal, a 9/11 responder whose foot was partially amputated after being crushed by an 8,000-pound piece of steel at Ground Zero, also admitted that the application process could become acrimonious.

“When you put a number or a label on it, it starts to exclude,” Feal, 56, told The Post.

Tim Brown, a former FDNY firefighter who ran into the Twin Towers to save people on Sept. 11, also admitted that “the devil is in the details” and said kinks may need to be ironed out by officials.

However, he wholeheartedly welcomes the announcement and may apply for one of the 80 affordable apartments.

“It really made me grateful that people actually thought of us,” Brown, 61, told The Post, adding that he’s been compelled to spend ample time at Ground Zero, despite the fact that he lost around 100 firefighter friends.


John Feal (right) with Jon Stewart
John Feal (right) is a 9/11 responder whose foot was partially amputated after being crushed at Ground Zero. He is pictured with Jon Stewart in 2019. “Anybody who risked their life should be entitled to affordable housing and not worried about putting food on the table,” he told The Post.
Getty Images

Tim Brown is a former FDNY officer who ran into the Twin Towers to save people on Sep. 11. He is pictured prior to his retirement.
Tim Brown, a retired FDNY firefighter, is pictured prior to his retirement: “A lot of the guys and the families I know don’t go back down there. It’s hard and painful, and understandably so. I reacted differently.”
Courtesy of Tim Brown

Renderings of the skyscraper showed that it looked directly out onto the somber 9/11 Memorial Pools at Ground Zero.
Renderings of the skyscraper showed that it looked directly onto the 9/11 memorial pools at Ground Zero.
Kohn Pedersen Fox

Brown, who has retired from the FDNY, now volunteers at the 9/11 Museum and hangs with friends at O’Hara’s — a pub popular with first responders past and present.

“I don’t think most people with my history react the way I react,” he admitted, saying most people impacted by 9/11 would be too traumatized to consider applying to live in 5 WTC. “A lot of the guys and the families I know don’t go back down there. It’s hard and painful, and understandably so. I reacted differently.”

Brown, a Manhattan native who lives in Midtown, said a move downtown could be life-changing.

“My heart is down there. I don’t find it morbid,” he told The Post, praising officials for doing a “wonderful job” in rebuilding the area around Ground Zero.

“Yes, 9/11 is my whole life,” Brown — who was 38 at the time of the attacks — said. “I didn’t have kids, I didn’t get married … To be able to get a reasonably priced rental down there would enable me to do other things that I’d like to do.”


Brown is seen at work with fellow FDNY on the day of the 9/11 attacks.
CBS

"9/11 is my whole life," Brown — who was just 38  at the time of the attacks — poignantly stated. "I didn't have kids, I didn't get married." He is pictured on Sep. 11 2001 with FDNY/OEM Ray Lynch.
“9/11 is my whole life,” Brown said. “I didn’t have kids, I didn’t get married.” He is pictured on Sept. 11, 2001, with FDNY/OEM member Ray Lynch.
Courtesy of Tim Brown

Meanwhile, Feal — who, along with comedian and political commentator Jon Stewart, has pushed to make permanent the September 11th Victim Compensation Fund — praised the decision to extend the affordable apartments to 9/11 survivors and first responders at 5 WTC, saying many had been pushed out of the city by soaring rents.

However, he encouraged officials to go further and create many more rent-stabilized options for the heroes still traumatized by the terrorist attacks.

“Anybody who risked their life should be entitled to affordable housing and not worried about putting food on the table,” he told The Post.


Gov. Hochul excitedly announced the deal late last month.
Gov. Kathy Hochul announced the deal last month.

The 900-foot skyscraper is being developed by a team led by Brookfield Properties and Silverstein Properties.
KPF

The building will feature some commercial space on the lower floors, but will primarily consist of residential space.
The building will feature some commercial space on the lower floors, but will primarily consist of residential space.
Silverstein Properties

But while the 9/11 survivors and first responders may be divided on whether they’d ever live at the site of their trauma, they are all still united in their grief as the 22nd anniversary of that fateful day fast approaches.

“The trauma never goes away,” Uchitel told The Post. “It’s something that’s in my bones. It’s a part of me.”

Fontana feels the same.

“It doesn’t feel like 22 years at all,” she mournfully stated. “Of course, you get up and you keep going. But you miss them all the time. You learn to live with it — but you never get over it.”



[ad_2]

Source link